Insights

Home » Insights » ​Litigation Over Profit-Sharing Agreements in NY Companies

​Litigation Over Profit-Sharing Agreements in NY Companies

by | Insights, Partnerships

Profit-sharing arrangements are very common in New York businesses and can provide employees, executives, partners, and other business associates with an incentive to grow and succeed. But despite how straightforward the agreement may have appeared, it can later create significant litigation risk if the parties disagree about how its terms were meant to be construed. Profit-sharing agreement disputes typically arise after a company becomes profitable, when ownership or management changes, or when parties attempt to calculate the amount allegedly owed.

What is a Profit-Sharing Agreement?

A profit-sharing agreement is a contract under which one party receives a portion of a company’s profits or other financial benefits. It may be contained in a formal employment agreement, partnership agreement, LLC operating agreement, shareholder agreement, compensation plan, or a separate written contract. In some cases, the arrangement may be less formal and have been conveyed through oral promises, emails, or the parties’ course of dealings.

Typically, profit-sharing agreements may promise a percentage of one or more of the following:

  • Net profits
  • Gross profits
  • Revenue
  • Distributions
  • Commissions
  • Sales proceeds
  • Incentive compensation
  • Profits from a specific transaction, project, or investment

The precise language used in the agreement can significantly impact the parties’ contractual rights.

Common Causes of Litigation Over Profit-Sharing Agreements

Disputes over profit-sharing agreements can occur at any stage of a business relationship. A dispute may begin with a simple question regarding how much a party was owed and quickly escalate into litigation involving financial records, accounting practices, contract interpretation, and an investigation into management conduct. These matters typically arise from vastly differing interpretations of how the agreement was supposed to operate. Common reasons for litigation over profit-sharing agreements include:

Disputes Over the Meaning of “Profits”

One of the most common reasons for litigation over profit-sharing agreements is how the term “profits” should be defined, and how profits should be calculated. For example, while parties may agree that 10% of profits should be shared, conflicts can arise if the agreement does not specify which expenses should be deducted before calculating the profit share.

A company may contend that profits are to be calculated after overhead, salaries, bonuses, taxes, and expenses have been taken into account. The party entitled to share in the profits may argue that certain expenses were improperly deducted or the agreement required a different calculation. Resolving a dispute may require a detailed review of the agreement, the parties’ communications, and the company’s financial records.

Allegations of Manipulated Finances

A party entitled to receive a percentage of a company’s profits may allege that the company improperly manipulated its finances to reduce or eliminate the amount owed. These allegations may involve inflated expenses, excessive compensation to owners or executives, shifting revenue between related companies, or other transactions that reduced reported profits. If such claims arise, they may require an extensive review of the company’s financial records and related-party transactions. Often, a forensic accountant may be necessary to determine whether the calculation of profits was accurate.

Failure to Pay Promised Profits

A company may face litigation when a party claims that it failed to make the payments required under the profit-sharing agreement. While the company may argue that no profits were generated, that payment was discretionary, or that the recipient failed to satisfy a condition of the agreement, the recipient may assert that the agreement created a binding obligation and that payment was withheld. In litigation, the language of the agreement is central to determining whether a payment obligation was triggered.

Disputes Over the Right to Payment When a Business Relationship Ends

Profit-sharing disputes frequently arise after an employee, executive, or other business associate leaves the company. The former participant may claim they earned a share of profits before the relationship ended, while the company may maintain that the right to profits ceased upon departure. Disagreements can also arise over whether the right to payment had already vested or depended on continued employment or ownership. In these cases, a court would generally evaluate the language of the governing agreement and the timing of the departure.

What Legal Claims Can Be Made in Profit-Sharing Disputes?

A dispute over a profit-sharing agreement may involve more than simply a disagreement over the amount of money owed. Depending on the circumstances surrounding the dispute, a party may assert a claim for breach of contract based on the failure to pay the amount allegedly required under the agreement. Other potential claims may include breach of fiduciary duty, fraud, conversion, and unjust enrichment, based on the nature of the parties’ relationship and the facts of the case.

The damages available to a plaintiff depend on the specific claim raised. A court may award unpaid amounts owed under the profit-sharing agreement, other economic losses, and additional damages permitted by applicable law if supported by the facts and circumstances of the case. A skilled business litigation attorney can best evaluate the available evidence and determine which legal claims and remedies may apply.

Contact an Experienced Long Island Business Litigation Attorney

If you are facing a dispute over a profit-sharing agreement, it’s vital to have an experienced business litigation attorney by your side. At Barnes & Barnes, P.C., we offer reliable representation for a wide range of business litigation matters across Long Island, including those involving profit-sharing disputes. Contact us at (516) 673-0674 to schedule a consultation and learn how we can assist you.

SEND US A MESSAGE

VIEW BY CATEGORY

ADDITIONAL INSIGHTS

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Subscribe to the Barnes & Barnes Newsletter, a valuable resource brimming with insights directly from commercial litigation partners, Leo K. Barnes, Jr. and Matthew J. Barnes.

Case Studies

Discover a few of the successes Barnes & Barnes has achieved for its clients between New York City and Montauk.